Official Stops on the Logan County Ice Cream Trail
Shakes At The Lake
13305 St Rt 235 N Lakeview, OH 43331
We are Indian Lake’s premier ice cream destination. We serve soft and hand dipped ice cream. We have a wide variety of shake, malt and slushee flavors. We specialize in sundaes and creamy Cyclone creations. We also have a wide variety of gourmet burgers and sandwiches.
101 Buckeye St W Belle Center, OH 43310
Local family owned and operated, the Belle Center Dairy Corner has been a tradition going back 50+ years. We are proud to make it our business in 2015! They offer soft serve, hand dipped, milkshakes, malts and specialty sundaes.
6700 Lima St Huntsville, OH 43324
You will find the best and freshest food at the Town Trolley. The handed dipped ice cream and yogurt is from the finest Ice Cream producers in Ohio. The Town Trolley prides itself on finding the highest quality best tasting products.
Whit’s Frozen Custard
112 S Main St Bellefontaine, OH 43311
Whit’s makes their frozen custard fresh every day so you can enjoy the best experience that frozen custard has to offer. And if you knew how much love and care they put into each batch of Whit’s frozen custard (they start at 6 am) you’d understand why we only feature three flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, and Whit’s Special Weekly Flavor.
City Sweet’s & Creamery
222 S Main St Bellefontaine, OH 43311
The Little Corner Sweet Shop for all those Sweet cravings. Including donuts made from scratch, cupcakes, cakes, Cookies, hand dipped ice cream and candy!
130 S Main St De Graff, OH 43318
This small side of the road stop is known for their good ice cream and fun staff! They have soft serve, sundae, fun flavored waffle cones and more. This is a can’t miss stop on the trail.
The Ice Cream Parlor
100 south Detroit Street West Liberty, OH 43357
Visit West Liberty’s old fashioned ice cream parlor. This small family owned store offers good old fashion hand scooped ice cream but also has many other options.
2793 Sandusky St Zanesfield, OH 43360
Firehouse pizza is better known for their food but they do offer ice cream also. This little eatery has a large dining room with a fire truck for kids to play on. They also have a beautiful outdoor patio to sit and enjoy your ice cream on.
The Donut Shop
104 E Main St Russells Point, OH 43348
The Donut Shop is an Indian Lake staple and are clearly more for their donuts but on any hot day during the summer you can head to this cute shop and get some delicious ice cream! It has such a fun Mom & Pop side of the road feeling.
Honey Bee’s Cafe & Ice Cream Shoppe
110 N Main St Lakeview, OH 43331
This new shop opened just last year in Downtown Lakeview. Its a perfect spot to stop and grab a sweet treat after a day on the lake.
Indian Lake State Park
13156 St Rt 235 North Lakeview, OH 43331
Did you know you can go to the Indian Lake State Park and just get ice cream? When you go tell the booth you are there for some ice cream and they will let you through to the commissary!
BONUS: Tilton Hilton Ice Cream Caboose
10861 Township Rd 293 Lakeview, OH 43331
Now this is truly a Logan County hidden treasure. If you have never been to the Tilton Hilton you have never experienced Indian Lake. The Tilton Hilton is know for well, being a little tilted, but, also their burgers. The Ice Cream Caboose is only open on Saturdays 12pm-9pm & Sundays 12pm-8pm in the summer so this will be a bonus stop. If you go here there will be an extra prize to collect!